(This post comes courtesy of Swamp superstar bapo!)
I’ve been a hockey fan forever. I love it for the same reasons that everybody else does — the speed, the skill, the grace, Ron Duguay’s hair, etc. — but lately I’ve been finding it harder and harder to defend. There’s nothing wrong with a hard-hitting game, as long as the hits are clean and meaningful, as long as the hits are used to separate a player from the puck, not the player’s head from his body.
The concussion problem is all the rage these days. Malcolm Gladwell is writing about it, Congress is capitalizing on it, Mike Leach is devising new treatment methods, and the NFL is taking steps to protect its players. People seem to be realizing that concussions are a serious issue and that big hits to the head shouldn’t be celebrated. (I don’t think that ESPN airs its “Jacked Up!” segment on Monday nights anymore.)
So, that’s progress. But in hockey, the culture of the game has to catch up. It’s great that injured players are going to receive better treatment, but they’re still getting injured at an alarming rate. In the NHL, we see replays a couple of times each week of borderline/dirty plays. It’s become commonplace. And the game at the lower levels is no better.
A couple of months ago, in an Ontario Hockey League game, Erie’s Michael Liambas tried to put Kitchener’s Ben Fanelli through the glass. Fanelli spent a few days in critical condition. He’s out of the hospital now, but he has no idea if he’ll ever play hockey again. Liambas (5 career goals, 357 penalty minutes) was suspended for the remainder of the season. I attended a game in Erie a couple of weeks later. First thing I saw when I walked in: an elderly woman wearing a Liambas jersey. Then I saw the autographed photos of Liambas at the souvenir stand. Before the game, a video tribute to Liambas aired, then Liambas walked out onto the ice and was mobbed by his teammates. Long, thunderous ovation from the Erie fans. I was a little ambivalent about the whole scene.
And then Patrice Cormier happened (link cotains graphic video footage). Cormier is a skilled player (2008 second-round pick of the New Jersey Devils) who already has a reputation for playing over the line. At the World Junior Championships a few weeks ago, he dished out two suspension-worthy elbows that did not actually result in a suspension. Yesterday, in a game in the Quebec Major Junior Hockey League, he lunged at Quebec’s Mikael Tam, hitting him in the face with his elbow. He wasn’t trying to slow Tam down. He wasn’t trying to separate him from the puck. No, he was trying to hurt him. Tam was knocked unconscious and went into convulsions. Early word is that he should be okay, though he’s missing a few teeth and had his jaw fractured. Cormier should be suspended for the rest of the season, but the QMJHL hasn’t announced its punishment yet.
The leagues, from the NHL to the minors to the juniors to the peewee level, need to address this. Occasionally, a Liambas or a Cormier will do something that is so ridiculously awful that he forces everybody to pay attention. But what about the elbows to the head that don’t result in a player convulsing on the ice? Is that just a part of the game? A high stick is called even if the guilty party did not intend to injure. But if Mike Richards knocks out David Booth? Well, Booth shouldn’t have been skating with his head down. (Booth has now missed 39 games for the Florida Panthers. Richards wasn’t even fined for his hit.)
The term “respect for the game” has been thrown around a lot the past few months. Players are so big and so fast, and a huge collision can happen on just about every shift. Lining people up, Scott Stevens-style, is an accepted part of the game now, with no regard for the health of the other player. I cringe when I see this because I can’t help but think of these players 20 or 30 years down the line. I love this sport, and I don’t want Patrice Cormier to be a part of it.